November 20, 2026.
SAULT STE. MARIE, Mich. The Sault Ste. Marie Tribe of Chippewa Indians has voted to approve a new constitution establishing a three-branch tribal government, but the results also raise questions about voter participation, reports of members not receiving ballots, and whether tribal citizens will pursue the federal process for challenging the election.
According to a November 20 announcement from the Sault Tribe, the secretarial election resulted in 2,697 votes in favor and 990 opposed, a margin of 1,707 votes. A majority of participating tribal citizens supported adopting the amended constitution.
However, the outcome represents only the votes cast, not necessarily the position of the broader tribal membership.
The election results raise questions about whether tribal member apathy and failure to participate among those who did not vote may have contributed to the proposal's approval. While 990 members voted against the amendment, many other eligible tribal citizens did not cast a ballot. Their reasons for not participating are unknown, and their positions cannot be assumed.
The distinction is important in an election that will fundamentally change the Tribe's governing structure and the relationship between tribal citizens and their elected leadership.
Reports of members not receiving ballots raise additional questions.
In addition to concerns about voter participation, rumors have circulated among tribal citizens that many members who wanted to vote never received their election ballots.
These reports have not been independently verified, and the reasons why any eligible voter may not have received a ballot remain unknown. At this point, there is no basis to attribute the reported circumstances to the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) or conclude that the BIA was responsible for any ballots that may not have been delivered.
The Sault Tribe's published election schedule stated that ballot packets would be mailed October 26 to eligible citizens who completed voter registration. Voter registration closed October 19.
Whether all registered voters received their ballots, whether mailing addresses were current, and whether any ballots were delayed, misdirected or otherwise undelivered are questions that have not yet been answered.
These reports could become relevant to an election challenge if affected members can document that they were eligible, registered to vote and did not receive their ballots.
Questioning whether every eligible registered voter had a fair opportunity to participate is not an accusation against the BIA. It is a legitimate election-process question that deserves clarification before the results are federally certified.
If substantiated, documented instances of registered voters being unable to participate could be among the issues brought forward for consideration during the federal election review.
What the election changes.
The amended constitution establishes three separate, co-equal branches of tribal government:
- Legislative: Responsible for making tribal laws.
- Executive: Responsible for administering government operations and carrying out laws.
- Judicial: Responsible for interpreting laws and resolving legal disputes.
The changes represent a significant departure from the 1975 Constitution, under which governing authority was largely concentrated within the Board of Directors.
Sault Tribe Chairman Austin Lowes described the outcome as a historic development, stating that the amendment establishes greater accountability, transparency and protections for tribal citizens.
The Tribe also plans to formally recognize the Mackinac Band's right to citizenship under the new constitutional framework.
The Board of Directors approved an 18-month Constitutional Implementation Plan on September 22. According to the Tribe's announcement, existing leadership, departments, programs, budgets and legal obligations generally will remain in place during the transition, subject to the amended constitution and applicable law.
Mackinac Band recognition does not eliminate federal recognition options.
The amended Sault Tribe Constitution's recognition of the Mackinac Band's right to citizenship should not be confused with federal tribal recognition or interpreted as preventing the Mackinac Band from independently pursuing federal acknowledgment.
The Mackinac Bands of Chippewa and Ottawa Indians are recognized by the State of Michigan as a State Historic Tribe. The State of Michigan has recognized the Band in that capacity since at least 2012. Michigan State University's Native @ MSU program also lists the Mackinac Bands among Michigan's state-recognized tribes, alongside three other historic tribal communities.
Michigan state recognition and recognition within another tribe's constitution are separate from federal acknowledgment. Neither, by itself, establishes federal recognition or prevents the Mackinac Band from pursuing it.
Under 25 CFR Part 83, the federal government maintains a separate administrative process through which tribal groups may petition the Department of the Interior for federal acknowledgment.
The regulations establish seven criteria for federal acknowledgment, including:
- Identification as an American Indian entity on a substantially continuous basis since 1900.
- Demonstration of a distinct community.
- Evidence of continuing political authority.
- An appropriate governing document.
- Evidence of tribal descent.
- Unique membership requirements.
- Compliance with congressional termination provisions.
Importantly, 25 CFR § 83.11(a)(2) specifically identifies relationships with state governments based on a group's identification as Indian as one form of evidence that may be considered in evaluating tribal identity.
The Mackinac Bands' state recognition and historical documentation therefore remain relevant to its separate federal recognition efforts, although they do not guarantee a favorable federal determination.
The federal regulations also provide for consideration of groups that can establish previous federal acknowledgment, subject to separate requirements.
The federal acknowledgment process is administered by the Bureau of Indian Affairs' Office of Federal Acknowledgment.
The distinction is important because the Sault Tribe's decision to recognize the Mackinac Band's right to citizenship does not determine the Band's federal status, eliminate its independent political identity, or take away its ability to pursue federal acknowledgment under applicable law.
Federal recognition information and regulations:
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-25/chapter-I/subchapter-F/part-83
Office of Federal Acknowledgment:
Michigan State University – Native @ MSU:
https://native.msu.edu/michigan-tribes/
Federal process for challenging the election.
Although the Tribe has announced the vote count, federal regulations provide an opportunity for eligible voters to challenge the results before the election is finalized.
Under 25 CFR § 81.43, a person who was included on the Eligible Voters List and submitted a voter registration form may challenge the results of a Secretarial election.
The regulation requires:
- A written challenge explaining the basis of the objection.
- Supporting evidence documenting the alleged election irregularities or errors.
- Submission to the Chairman of the Secretarial Election Board.
- Receipt of the challenge within five days after the Certificate of Results of Election is posted. The day the certificate is posted is not counted.
Challenges received after the deadline will not be considered.
The federal regulation is available here:
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-25/chapter-I/subchapter-F/part-81/subpart-D/section-81.43
Election challenge deadline: November 24, 2026.
The Sault Tribe's official Secretarial Election information identifies November 24, 2026, at 4:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time as the deadline for submitting written challenges.
The Tribe identifies Nicholas Van Alstine as Chairman of the Secretarial Election Board.
Challenges must be supported by evidence and received by the deadline. The regulation specifies that the challenge must be received by the Chairman of the Secretarial Election Board, not merely sent to a general BIA office.
The posting date of the Certificate of Results is the date that determines the federal filing period.
Where to direct election inquiries.
Secretarial Election Board Chairman: Nicholas Van Alstine.
The Sault Tribe identifies Van Alstine as the person to receive written election challenges.
Bureau of Indian Affairs – Michigan Agency.
2845 Ashmun Street
Sault Ste. Marie, MI 49783
Telephone: 906-632-6809
Fax: 906-632-0689
Superintendent: Jason Oberle.
The BIA Michigan Agency is the federal office located in Sault Ste. Marie. The agency's published telephone number can be used for inquiries concerning the federal election process.
BIA Michigan Agency information:
https://www.bia.gov/regional-offices/midwest/michigan-agency
What happens if an objection is filed?
Under 25 CFR § 81.45, the Department of the Interior reviews election challenges and the election results.
If a challenge establishes errors that would invalidate the election and the federal authorizing official sustains the challenge, the official may authorize a recount or call for a new Secretarial election.
If challenges are denied or dismissed, the federal government proceeds with its review, including whether:
- The required voter participation threshold was met.
- The voters accepted or rejected the proposed amendments.
- The proposed constitutional amendments comply with federal law.
The Sault Tribe's published election requirements specify that at least 30% of registered voters must participate, in addition to a majority of ballots cast supporting the amendments.
Although 3,687 votes were reported, the total number of registered voters has not been provided in the November 20 announcement. Therefore, the actual participation percentage cannot be determined from the announced vote totals alone.
A decision that will affect generations.
The approval of the amended constitution marks a major turning point for the Sault Tribe. However, the election outcome should also prompt a broader discussion about tribal citizen participation and the responsibility of members to remain informed and engaged in decisions affecting their government.
With 990 members voting against the amendment, there is a substantial group of citizens whose concerns should not be dismissed simply because the proposal received more favorable votes.
Likewise, the absence of votes from other eligible citizens should not automatically be interpreted as support for the changes.
Reports that some members who wanted to participate did not receive ballots also deserve clarification. Whether those reports can be substantiated, and whether they identify procedural problems that affected the election, remains to be determined.
The federal review and certification process provides an opportunity for documented concerns to be examined. For eligible voters who believe there were procedural violations, errors in the election process, or other grounds for challenging the results, the federal objection period provides a limited opportunity to have those concerns formally considered.
The amended constitution will not take effect until the Secretary of the Interior approves and certifies the election results.