Bad River Band and Enbridge Propose New Court Oversight as Line 5 Reroute Nears Completion.

November 17, 2026. 

Enbridge reports reroute is approximately 90% complete, with early 2027 completion projected; parties remain divided over restitution owed for pipeline trespass.

A new court filing in the long-running dispute between the Bad River Band of the Lake Superior Tribe of Chippewa Indians and Enbridge Energy outlines a proposed schedule for monitoring the company's Line 5 reroute and determining the amount of restitution Enbridge may owe for operating the pipeline across tribal allotment lands without valid rights-of-way.

The six-page Joint Proposal for Remand Proceedings, filed November 12, 2026, in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin, follows a July 30 decision by the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals that affirmed Enbridge's trespass on 12 parcels of Bad River Band land but sent the questions of restitution and injunctive relief back to the district court.

The filing reports that Enbridge considers the Wisconsin reroute approximately 90% complete and projects that construction will be completed by early 2027. That progress estimate and completion date are Enbridge's reported figures, not an independent finding by the court.

Proposed 60-day progress reports.

Under the joint proposal, Enbridge would submit a status report to the court every 60 days, beginning December 15, 2026, providing updates on the reroute schedule.

Enbridge would provide each report to the Bad River Band 10 days before filing it with the court. The Band would then have an opportunity to provide its position on the report, which Enbridge would include in its court filing.

The parties propose that they return to the court to address whether an injunction is still necessary, along with any related discovery, hearing dates or other issues.

The proposal reflects the Seventh Circuit's direction that the district court provide Enbridge a reasonable opportunity to complete the reroute while ensuring the company's trespass does not continue without oversight or accountability.

Importantly, the November 12 document is a joint proposal submitted by the parties and requests court approval. Its proposed reporting schedule should not be confused with a final ruling approving every term.

Restitution remains disputed.

The filing also outlines a separate process for determining the financial restitution Enbridge may owe the Band.

In its July decision, the Seventh Circuit vacated the district court's original restitution award of $5,151,668 and ordered a new calculation. The appeals court found that the lower court had improperly combined two different methods of calculating restitution: Enbridge's profits and the value of costs it allegedly delayed by continuing to use the pipeline rather than completing the reroute.

The Band and Enbridge now disagree over which measure should be used.

The Band supports an award based at least on the value of the delayed costs. Enbridge argues that any award should be limited to a prorated share of total profits, calculated using the portion of the pipeline in trespass and the Band's weighted ownership interest in the affected parcels.

The parties propose that the court first decide which restitution method is appropriate before ordering additional factual and expert discovery.

Their proposed briefing schedule calls for:

  • February 5, 2027: Simultaneous opening briefs, limited to 30 pages each, excluding exhibits.
  • March 5, 2027: Simultaneous response briefs, also limited to 30 pages each, excluding exhibits.

The parties also requested an opportunity to present oral arguments after the briefs are submitted.

Within 45 days after the court decides which method to use, the parties propose submitting a plan for the remaining proceedings, including additional factual and expert discovery, disclosure deadlines, and potential trial dates.

The filing notes that some of the financial information used in the original proceedings is now incomplete or outdated. With the reroute reportedly nearing completion, the final project costs may be more accurately determined if the court selects a measure that makes those costs relevant. Enbridge's profits may also be examined through additional discovery.

What the appeals court decided.

The dispute began with the Band's 2019 lawsuit challenging Enbridge's continued operation of Line 5 across parcels where the company's rights-of-way had expired.

The Seventh Circuit's July 30, 2026 decision affirmed that Enbridge had been trespassing on the 12 allotted parcels since June 2013. It also affirmed that restitution and a permanent injunction remain available remedies for the trespass.

However, the appeals court vacated the original restitution award and the district court's injunction, directing the lower court to reconsider the remedies and allow Enbridge a reasonable opportunity to complete the reroute.

The appeals court also reversed the Band's federal public nuisance claim, finding that federal pipeline safety law displaces that claim. The related monitoring and shutdown requirements imposed under the nuisance ruling were vacated.

The appeals court did not eliminate the requirement that Enbridge remove Line 5 from the affected parcels. It directed the district court to establish a reasonable timetable and appropriate oversight to ensure the reroute is completed.

What happens next.

The immediate next milestone under the parties' proposal is Enbridge's first 60-day status report, scheduled for December 15, 2026.

The restitution dispute will continue into 2027, with the proposed February and March briefing dates followed by oral argument if the court grants the parties' request.

The case remains an important test of tribal property rights and the remedies available when a pipeline company continues operating across tribal allotment lands after its rights-of-way have expired.

Although the proposed reroute may bring the physical trespass closer to an end, the financial dispute and the court's final decisions on injunctive relief remain unresolved.